FAQ
36 answered questions22 official
Rules questions from the BoardGameGeek forum. Answers marked Official were confirmed by Board&Dice or the designers.
Common mistakes
- Treating Extra Potency as a substitute for all Potency on a Main action. Ruling · Rule
- All Transmutations share one ordinary Artifact activation; explicit activation rewards are additional. Resolve the immediate effect of an acquired Artifact separately. Ruling · Rule
- Scoring a Theory tile from an incomplete Publication section. Ruling · Rule
- Gold-paid Book costs increase across all Elements, and only one Book per Element can be bought with Gold during the game. Ruling · Rule
- A Familiar may be tamed only once per turn as that Free-action type; its effects still apply to every relevant Transmutation. Ruling · Rule
Showing 36 of 36
When can I use a Free action during my turn? Official
Yes. You may take Free actions before or after each Potency spent, including between individual Transmutations. Complete an individual Transmutation before using its result for the next one. Keep each Free-action type’s once-per-turn limit and any specific timing restriction, such as changing your die before the Main action.
Source: Free-action thread; exact publisher reply.
Can Extra Potency pay for my whole Main action?
No. Spend exactly one Extra Potency before the Main action, and still spend at least one Potency from the active die. Extra Potency cannot be used to take an Experiment.
Source: 2026 rulebook, Free actions.
Can I activate more than one Artifact in a turn? Official
All Transmutations during your turn share one ordinary Artifact activation, including bonus Transmutations from Batteries or other effects. An explicit activation reward, shown by the exclamation-mark Artifact icon, is additional and can grant another activation. Do not create a new ordinary allowance for each bundle of Transmutations.
This also applies to an Artifact gained as a reward rather than bought with Potency. When you gain an Artifact during play, resolve its acquisition effect and place it ready. That immediate effect is separate from exhausting it through an activation. The starting Artifact is not resolved during setup.
Source: Publisher clarification of the shared limit and extra activations; gaining an Artifact.
Source: 2026 rulebook, Artifacts and Transmutations.
How does the Lead-to-Tin Artifact with the misprinted number work? Official
Pay 1 Lead to gain 2 Tin, up to twice. The top “1” should be red: it is a payment, not a free Lead gain before the exchange.
Source: Publisher misprint correction.
Can an Artifact activated after one Transmutation supply a Metal for my next Transmutation?
Yes. Finish the first Transmutation, then resolve the eligible Artifact. A Metal it supplies may be used for a later Transmutation that turn. It cannot retrospectively pay for the Transmutation that triggered it. The shared ordinary activation limit still applies.
Source: BGG clarification.
Does a Theory tile score if its Publication section is incomplete?
No. A Theory tile scores only when every icon in its Publication section is covered. Multiply the printed Theory value by that section's Publication value.
Source: 2026 rulebook, Final Scoring.
Can one Wild Artifact count for more than one Theory tile? Official
Yes. Treat a Wild Artifact as any required Element when covering Publication icons and scoring Theory tiles. It can count for both a red-Artifact Theory and a blue-Artifact Theory; you do not have to lock it to one colour for the whole scoring.
Source: Publisher Wild Artifact answer; double-counting clarification.
Does a Theory showing Experiments and Artifacts score pairs? Official
Count the matching completed Experiments and Artifacts separately, not pairs. Six matching Experiments and three matching Artifacts count as nine objects before applying the Publication multiplier. A scoring object may contribute to multiple applicable Theory conditions; Wild Artifacts count as the required Element in each.
Source: BGG clarification. BGG clarification.
What if I gain an Element but have no matching or Wild space left?
An Experiment without an available matching or Wild Publication icon gives 1 VP instead. With Expert Study, use its matching available space and printed reward instead.
Source: 2026 rulebook, Experiments and Expert Study.
Can I buy both Books of one Element with Gold?
No. Each Element supplies one Book from its first completed Experiment and one bought with Gold; you may acquire them in either order. Gold-paid Books cost 1, 2, 3 and 4 Gold across all Elements, not separately for each Element. Books from Experiments do not increase that cost. The Gold Free action can be used once per turn, and only once per Element during the whole game.
May I flip my Patron to the other side after choosing it? Official
No. Put the Patron tiles into the draft on random sides and keep the side showing when you choose yours. The A/B choice for easier or expert play refers to the Publication sideboard; players may use different sides of that sideboard.
[Batteries] May I discard a Battery to replace it when I already have three? Official
No. You cannot exchange a Battery for another one to get around the three-Battery limit, which includes your basic Battery.
Source: Publisher Battery ruling.
[Batteries] Does the one-to-three-Metals Experiment use my die's Potency? Official
No. Pay one to three Metals matching the active die's symbol; the die's Potency is not the payment count. If that die was exhausted earlier this turn, still use the symbol it had when the turn began.
[Batteries] When do I gain an additional Battery?
Resolve the Battery-gain icon when a reward grants it, for example on the module’s added Experiments or Mastery Reward tiles. Including the module does not itself grant a Battery every turn. Keep the three-Battery limit, including the basic Battery.
Source: BGG clarification. Battery module rules, p.18.
Which Book does the Homunculus move when spending Gold? Official
Move its bottom-shelf Books from left to right. Pay the printed increasing costs, 1 Gold for the first, 2 for the second, and so on, and resolve the reward of the space covered.
Source: Publisher left-to-right ruling; 2026 solo rulebook, p.8.
Does the Homunculus need its eighth Book to score 36 VP?
No. Seven Books already score 36 VP, as for a human player. It may move its eighth Book even without Expert Study and receive that space's reward, but its Book score stays capped at 36 VP. The Homunculus uses its own Study for these Books.
Source: 2026 solo rulebook, pp.8 and 10; BGG scoring clarification.
What if the Homunculus has no ready Artifact when told to exhaust one? Official
With no ready Artifact, ignore that exhaust-an-Artifact action. This does not cancel the other actions on the Decision card.
Source: BGG clarification.
Does an Element the Homunculus cannot place give VP? Official
Yes. It gains 1 VP for an Element it cannot place. With Expert Study, apply that module’s alternate placement rule when available instead; this is not permission to ignore its special rule.
Source: BGG clarification. Solo rules, pp.7 and 10.
Are advancement arrows missing on Decision cards S6 and S10? Official
Yes. The upward arrows for advancing on the lowest Mastery track are missing from S6 and S10. Treat the indicated effect as an advancement, rather than as a reference to the current track position.
Source: BGG clarification.
[Familiars] Can I tame more than one Familiar in a turn? Official
No. Taming is one Free-action type, so you may tame only one Familiar per turn. A Familiar's effects are separate: they apply to each Transmutation in its section, including bonus Transmutations. Pay its Mischievous requirements each time; Benevolent rewards may be declined.
Source: Publisher Free-action clarification; per-Transmutation ruling.
[Familiars] Can I Transmute at 0 VP when a Mischievous Familiar requires losing 1 VP? Official
No. At 0 VP you cannot pay the required penalty, so that Transmutation is unavailable. The printed minimum of zero does not make the penalty optional.
Source: BGG clarification.
[Familiars] Does the Young Dog’s extra move also advance Mastery? Official
Yes. Its bonus Transmutation is restricted to the same Metal token. Pay Essence or Mercury normally for that extra move and advance the corresponding Mastery track.
Source: BGG clarification.
[Familiars] Must I use Earth Essence to gain the Adult Rabbit’s Earth advancement? Official
No. Its bonus Earth step is additional. You may pay for the Transmutation and advance another Mastery track, then receive the Familiar’s Earth advancement.
Source: BGG clarification.
[Familiars] Does the Potency track carry over between rounds? Official
No. The Potency track used for Familiar assignment resets after each round. Do not carry its total into the next round.
Source: BGG clarification.
Does a bonus Experiment-card gain cost Potency or depend on my die colour? Official
A reward that grants an Experiment card is not the Take an Experiment Main action, so it does not charge that action’s 1 Potency. When an Artifact or Battery grants the card, you are not limited by your active die’s colour: choose from the offer and refill the Main-offer slot immediately. Keep your two-card hand limit and follow any restriction printed on the particular effect.
Source: BGG clarification. BGG clarification.
Can Aqua Regia reduce an Experiment’s Mastery requirement to zero? Official
Yes. Spend multiple Aqua Regia tokens to reduce the requirement to zero. This reduces the Mastery requirement, not the Experiment’s Metal payment.
Source: BGG clarification.
What does the Experiment reward showing an exhausted die give? Official
Gain one unrefined Metal matching one of your exhausted dice. If you have no exhausted die, there is no matching Metal to gain.
Source: BGG clarification. Follow-up about having no exhausted die.
How is the Excess offer formed, and does it refill?
In Preparation for rounds two and three, discard the previous Excess offer and move the three rightmost cards of the old Main offer into the new Excess offer. Rebuild the Main offer for the new round. Excess cards do not refill when taken; Main-offer cards do. The printed instruction does not say to take one card from each colour zone.
Source: BGG clarification. 2026 rulebook, p.11.
Does spending Essence always advance Mastery? Official
No: spending Essence on an Artifact exchange does not advance Mastery. Essence or Mercury spent specifically on a Transmutation advances its matching Mastery track. Use the resource spent to choose the track, rather than the starting or destination Metal. Spending Mercury this way advances the Mercury track.
Source: BGG clarification. BGG clarification. BGG clarification.
Must I waive the Essence cost when an effect offers a cost-free Transmutation? Official
No. You may decline the Essence waiver, pay Essence or Mercury normally and advance the matching Mastery track. If you use the waiver, do not advance Mastery for an Essence or Mercury payment you did not make.
Source: BGG clarification.
Do bonus Transmutations spend die Potency?
A Transmutation granted as a reward does not spend die Potency. Pay its normal Essence or Mercury cost unless the reward explicitly waives it. This differs from spending Potency on the Transmutation Main action.
Source: BGG clarification. 2026 rulebook, pp.14 and 24.
Can I choose Refining as a Main or Free action?
No. Resolve Refining only when an effect grants it. It is separate from a Transmutation and does not spend Essence or advance Mastery.
Source: BGG clarification. 2026 rulebook, p.9.
Can I draft another die while I still have an active die?
No. Draft only when you have no die on your Potency track. An inconvenient colour or face does not permit you to keep two active dice.
Source: BGG clarification. 2026 rulebook, pp.11–12.
Do I reroll a pool with five dice or six?
Reroll every die in a pool containing six or more dice, then redistribute by face. Repeat until every pool has at most five. “More than five” and “six or more” are the same threshold.
Source: BGG clarification. 2026 rulebook, p.11.
Does the VP dial cap my score at 99?
No. Continue tracking points beyond 99 using the 100-VP marker. A two-digit dial is not a scoring cap.
Source: BGG clarification.
Does Silver retain its special first-edition ability?
Do not import a first-edition Silver ability into this edition. Use Silver for the payments and Transmutation paths printed in the new edition; the older special effect is not an additional rule.
Source: BGG clarification. New-edition Metals and Transmutations, pp.9 and 14.