FAQ
19 answered questions5 official
Rules questions from the BoardGameGeek forum. Answers marked Official were confirmed by Mindclash Games or the designers.
Common mistakes
Showing 19 of 19
If a Magician’s ability adds to a Trick yield and a Special Assignment doubles that yield, do I apply the addition before or after doubling?
The community answer says the player may choose the order of yield modifiers and use the more favorable result. The thread points to a designer post about a separate yield-modifier combination, but this answer itself is not marked as a designer ruling. Check the specific card text and the current rulebook if the combination differs.
Source: BGG thread
Can I place one character on Thursday and, on my next turn, place another on Friday before the next Performance phase?
No. Choose one weekday for all your Characters placed in the Theater during that game turn. Later placement opportunities in the same turn do not let you switch from Thursday to Friday. The chosen weekday must not already be occupied by an opponent.
Source: BGG thread; revised core rules, pp.16–17
[Arcane] Can I mix Wagon actions with the ordinary location’s actions? Official
Yes. Split the placed Character’s AP between Arcanist actions and ordinary actions at the Wagon’s current location. The Character still occupies that location’s slot and uses its AP modifier. You do not place a worker on the Arcanist board.
Official — Designer confirmed: Dávid Turczi (TDaver). Direct reply
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.3–5
[Arcane] Can I spend a Shard when using the Arcanist actions?
Yes. Enhance the Character at the Wagon’s location under the ordinary enhancement limit. One ordinary Shard gives +1 AP or one Arcane Shard gives +2 AP; do not pay both for +3 AP in one placement. Arcane Shards have a separate +1 AP enhancement exception in the Theater.
Source: BGG discussion; BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.6
[Arcane] Can I enchant a Trick whose components I already own?
Yes. During Prepare, Enchantments can substitute for components you already own as well as missing ones. Each tile substitutes for up to two Coins’ worth; use one type at a time and bind exactly one of the tiles used to the Trick.
Source: BGG discussion; BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.9–10
[Arcane] If I use two Enchantments to Prepare, what happens to the second?
Move exactly one used tile onto the Trick. The other stays in your Workshop and can substitute for components of another eligible Trick. Both tiles contribute their substitution value to this Prepare, but the bound tile is no longer in your component supply afterwards.
Source: BGG discussion; BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.9–10
[Arcane] Can I Prepare an enchanted Trick again using real components? Official
Yes. Meet the ordinary component requirements and Prepare it normally; you do not add another Enchantment. A bound Enchantment does not grant a lasting component discount, and that same type cannot substitute again for this Trick. A different type may substitute and enchant it further.
Official — Designer confirmed: Dávid Turczi (TDaver). Direct reply
Source: BGG discussion; BGG discussion; BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.9–10
[Arcane] Do I get an Enchantment reward when another player performs my Trick? Official
No. Your own Magician must perform the card containing your matching enchanted Trick for its Arcane die reward. You still receive the Trick’s ordinary yield when another Magician performs it. Matching Tricks in Classrooms have their separate Classroom reward rule.
Official — Designer confirmed: Dávid Turczi (TDaver). Direct reply
Source: BGG discussion; BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.10–12
[Arcane] Does ignoring the Enchantment die trigger several types on one Trick? Official
Yes. While that Prophecy is active, each different Enchantment on an eligible Trick triggers the reward. Two different types therefore give two rewards, and three give three. You must still be the Magician performing the Trick in the Theater; this does not turn guest Tricks into Arcane rewards. Classroom rewards remain separate.
Official — Designer confirmed: Dávid Turczi (TDaver). Direct reply
Source: BGG discussion; BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.13
[Arcane] Can I add an Enchantment after a Trick is already in a Classroom?
No. Enchanting happens during Prepare, and a taught Trick cannot be prepared again. Enchant it before teaching; it can then trigger its matching reward during the Classroom phase.
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.9–12; Academy rules, pp.9,11
[Arcane] Does an Enchantment satisfy a Level 3 Trick’s final component requirement?
No. Enchantments substitute only during Prepare, not when checking final scoring or teaching. With Academy, a separate rule lets a Level 3 Trick qualify through at least one Trick marker remaining on it. Without Academy, Arcane Arts does not itself grant that alternative.
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.10; Academy rules, p.12
[Arcane] Is the Level 3 Fame threshold 32 or 36?
The revised core rule is 36 Fame for Level 3. Arcane Arts’ reward example showing 32 does not introduce a replacement threshold. Its die reward is Fame equal to the Trick’s Level: three Fame for a Level 3 Trick.
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.11; revised core rules, p.14
[Arcane] Must every other worker be marked Idle before I send Golem last? Official
No. Golem may be your last actually sent Character while you use later placement opportunities to mark remaining Characters Idle. After a Golem sent as your last Character, you cannot send another Character that turn. This preserves the option to delay an Idle choice until its normal opportunity.
Official — Designer confirmed: Dávid Turczi (TDaver). Direct reply
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.7
[Arcane] Can Shapeshifter count as a Magician or change type between final bonuses?
No. It may count as an Apprentice or one of the three Specialists for other effects, and it chooses one type for the whole final scoring. It cannot be an Engineer for one end-game Trick and a Manager for another. Its Theater bonus can instead charge one ordinary Shard to an available Arcane Shard; that icon does not turn it into a Magician.
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.8–9
[Arcane] Do Engineer and Shapeshifter double Buried Alive to fourteen Fame?
No. The revised core bonus gives seven Fame if you have an Engineer; it does not give seven per Engineer. Counting Shapeshifter as a second Engineer does not repeat that bonus. You may choose a different eligible type for Shapeshifter, consistently for all final scoring.
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.9; revised core rules, p.22
[Arcane] Can the Heir have several Tricks with the same Enchantment type?
Yes. Exclude a type from its first Arcanist priority only when all its Tricks already carry that type, not merely when one does. The chosen tile immediately enchants the first Trick from left to right lacking that type. If all eligible owned-type counts are zero, the printed cheaper-tile tie breaker still matters.
Source: BGG discussion; Arcane Arts V2, pp.14
Must I move components off the Manager before using them to Prepare?
No. Components on the Manager’s extension are part of your Workshop and can meet a Trick’s requirements immediately. Each occupied multi-component slot counts as one extra of the type stacked there, including for the limit of three. Move Components costs 1 AP to rearrange or exchange a pile, not to make its components usable. Components are not consumed by Prepare; the extra counted component does not become a physical piece when you move its pile away.
Can an Apprentice use the Specialist movement actions in the Workshop?
Yes. After you have the respective Specialist, any Character placed in your Workshop may use these actions for 1 AP each. Move Tricks moves or exchanges a Trick with the Engineer’s slot. Move Components moves or exchanges a component pile with a Manager slot. Move Apprentice permanently transfers one Apprentice and its Assignment card, if any, to the Assistant’s empty Apprentice slot. The acting Character does not have to be that Specialist.
Source: BGG discussion; revised core rules, p.16
Can I leave an assigned Character Idle instead of sending it out?
Yes. On its placement opportunity, turn that Character’s Assignment card face down and leave the Character on your board instead of placing it. It receives no wages at the end of the turn. For a Character you do place, use its Action Points immediately at that location; unused Action Points cannot be saved for a later placement.