FAQ
28 answered questions19 official
Rules questions from the BoardGameGeek forum. Answers marked Official were confirmed by Catch Up Games or the designers.
Common mistakes
Showing 28 of 28
Does a discount apply only to my next purchase?
No. It remains active for later purchases from the matching location. It does not discount the character that grants it, and a price cannot go below zero.
Source: BGG thread; official rules, p.7
Must I place my first card immediately?
Yes. Place it and resolve its ability right away. Later cards determine its eventual position in the three-by-three grid; that flexibility does not delay its immediate effect.
Source: BGG thread; official rules, pp.7–9
Are Gold, Keys and the discard piles public? Official
Yes. Anyone may look through both discard piles at any time; if that slows your table down, agree a limit. Gold and Keys stay visible on the table, since nothing in the game is hidden.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
Can one Key both move the Messenger and refresh a row?
No. A Key does one of the two: move the Messenger to the other location, or discard and replace the three cards where the Messenger already is. To refresh the other row, you need a second Key.
Source: BGG thread · official rules, p.7
Who is a "neighbor"?
The player directly to your left or right; in a four-player game, the player opposite is not a neighbor. Effects that count a neighbor's symbols count that player's whole tableau, so they can be worth several Gold or Keys.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread · official rules, p.9
Can I take a card face down even if I could afford it? Official
Yes. It is often a good move when the current choices are weak. The card must still come from the location where the Messenger is.
Source: BGG thread
Can I keep taking cards face down to farm Gold and Keys? Official
No. A face-down card fills one of your nine tableau spaces, so you take at most nine cards in the whole game, face up or face down.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
Does the Messenger move when I take a card face down?
No. Ignore any Messenger icon on a card taken face down.
Source: BGG thread · official rules, p.9
Does a face-down card count as a Castle or Village card, or for its shields? Official
No. Everything printed on a face-down card is ignored, when it is placed and at game end (for example, it does not count for the Usurper).
Source: BGG thread
Does a face-down card count as an occupied space? Official
Yes. Woodcutter and Beggar give 1 Gold per occupied space, which is one per card you have placed, face-down cards included.
Source: BGG thread
Can I spend Gold that is on a purse? Official
No. Gold on a purse stays there and only scores at game end. Leftover Gold goes onto purses only when the game ends, but some effects add Gold to purses during play.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread · BGG thread
Where does the Gold come from when an effect fills purses? Official
From the general supply, not from your own Gold.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
Must the Steward fill its own purse? Official
No. Choose any two purses in your tableau; the Steward's own purse may be one of them.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
Does the Banker score my leftover Gold? Official
Only Gold that ends up on purse cards. In effect, each Gold on a purse scores 1 extra point.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
Does Gold on purses count for the tie-break? Official
No. Once on a purse it is points, not Gold. Only Gold left in your supply breaks ties.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
Does the General score sets of different shield types? Official
Yes. Each set of three identical shields scores, whatever the type: six Faith and six Peasantry shields make four sets.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
What does the half card on the Carpenter mean? Official
It is a face-down card: score 8 points if your tableau has at least one.
Source: BGG thread
For cards that score shields in their row and column, does their own shield count twice?
No. The card sits in both lines but its shield counts once.
Source: BGG thread
What does the Alchemist count?
Every card in your tableau with a discount ability, whether for the Castle, the Village or both, including the Alchemist itself.
Source: BGG thread
When an effect discards one of the three cards of a location, which cards does it mean?
The cards on display at that location, not cards in your tableau.
Source: BGG thread
When I activate an adjacent card's ability, which position does it use? Official
The activated card's own position. The effect activates that card rather than copying it, which matters for effects that count its row or column.
Source: BGG thread
[Oubliette] Can I activate a Lock as soon as I buy its card? Official
Yes, at the end of that turn after refilling the displays. You may activate at most one Lock on each of your own turns. The other windows are before your normal Key decision, or after using that Key but before buying.
[Oubliette] Can I use a Lock at the start of my turn without spending a Key on the Messenger? Official
Yes. Spending a Key is not required. If you do spend one, refreshing a row counts as using the Messenger just like moving it, so the Lock can come before or after either.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread
[Oubliette] Where does the Key on a Lock card come from? Official
From the general supply, so you get it even with no Keys of your own.
Source: BGG thread
[Oubliette] Can I spend the Key on a Lock for something else, such as moving the Messenger? Official
No. It is not in your Key pool. You can only remove it to trigger that Lock, or keep it for game-end scoring.
Source: BGG thread
[Oubliette] Does copying a Lock spend the Key on the adjacent card? Official
No. A copied Lock does not spend the target card’s Key and works even without one. The target must be orthogonally adjacent, and a permanent discount cannot be chosen.
[Oubliette] If I activate a Lock card through an adjacent card, can I still use its own Lock later?
Yes. When you later remove its Key, the Lock triggers as normal.
Source: BGG thread
[Oubliette] Do Keys left on unused Locks score points? Official
Yes. Add them to your Keys at game end before scoring. They are then worth the normal one point each.