FAQ
59 answered questions19 official
Rules questions from the BoardGameGeek forum. Answers marked Official were confirmed by Roxley or the designers.
Common mistakes
- Discard one card for each action and each pass; Scout also needs two extra cards. Ruling · Rule
- An overbuild still uses the lowest remaining Industry tile of that type. Ruling · Rule
- Merchant beer belongs to the Merchant being sold to; take its bonus when you consume it. Ruling · Rule
- Flipping raises income now; Industry tile VPs are scored only at era end. Ruling · Rule
- Equally close Coal Mines: pick one and take all the coal from it; don't split. Ruling · Rule
- Opponents' Coal Mines and Iron Works can be overbuilt only when no cube of that type is left anywhere, Market included. Ruling · Rule
Showing 59 of 59
How many cards do I discard for an action?
Discard one card for each action, including each action you pass. Scout also requires two additional cards, so it costs three cards in total. Return a Wild card to its face-up area instead of placing it in your Discard Pile.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Does a Sell action that flips several tiles cost more than one card?
No. A Build and a Sell each cost one card. One Sell action can flip as many of your Cotton Mills, Manufacturers and Potteries as you can connect and supply with beer.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I take the same action twice in one turn?
Yes. Two Builds, two Sells or two Network actions (up to four rail Links) are all legal if you can pay for them. Scout is the exception in practice: after the first Scout you hold Wild cards, so you cannot Scout again.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can my second action pay for or enable my first?
No. Finish each action completely before starting the next. Money, coal or a connection gained in your second action cannot be used for the first.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Why is one card dealt face down into my Discard Pile at setup?
It starts your Discard Pile and balances the Canal Era: with one card set aside, everyone takes a single action in the first round and the deck runs out on time. Don't look at it; it is turned face up and shuffled in at the start of the Rail Era.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can players look through the Discard Piles? Official
By the rules they are open. In tournaments, keep them open. In casual games, the cards played this round should always be shared on request; how far back you dig is up to the player you ask, so don't slow the game down. Groups may house-rule this.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread · BGG thread
Can I look at the face-down card in my Discard Pile? Official
No. Nobody may look at it during the Canal Era. If someone looks by mistake, they discard it and draw a replacement.
Source: BGG thread · BGG Rules forum
Is money public? Official
Yes. All money is public knowledge; you may not hide coins.
Source: BGG thread
Which card can I use to build?
A Location card builds in that named location, even outside your network. An Industry card builds the matching industry in a location that is part of your network. Wild cards stand in for either, except that a Wild Location card cannot be used for a Farm Brewery.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I use money from selling the new tile's coal or iron to pay for building it?
No. Pay the full cost first; cubes are moved to the Market and paid for only after the tile is on the board.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I skip lower-level Industry tiles when I overbuild?
No. Overbuilding follows the normal Build rule: take the lowest remaining tile of that industry from your Player Mat. Develop lower tiles away first if you need to reach a higher level.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I overbuild with a different industry, or with a tile of the same level?
No. The new tile must be the same industry and a higher level than the tile it replaces, even on a space that shows two industry icons. You still need a card that lets you build there.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
When can I overbuild an opponent's tile?
Only their Coal Mine or Iron Works, and only when there are no cubes of that resource anywhere on the board: not on any tile and not in the Market. Other industries, including Breweries, can be overbuilt only by their owner.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I overbuild my own tile while the location still has empty spaces?
Yes, overbuilding your own tiles has no extra restriction. It does not get around the Canal Era limit, though: you still may have only one Industry tile in each location in that era.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum
What happens to the resources on an overbuilt tile, and how is the new tile placed? Official
Coal, iron and beer left on the old tile go back to the General Supply. The new tile goes down unflipped and is stocked as a fresh build; a new Coal Mine or Iron Works then fills its Market as usual.
Source: BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
Do I lose income or VPs when my tile is overbuilt?
No. Income and VPs already gained stay. The overbuilt tile is removed from the game, so it scores nothing at the end of the current era.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
What if no beer is left anywhere and nobody can sell? Official
There is always a way, it just costs actions: build a Brewery, Scout for Wild cards if you lack a Brewery card or location, or overbuild one of your own flipped Breweries with a fresh one.
Source: BGG thread
Does a location need one of my Industry tiles to be in my network? Official
No. Every location next to one of your Link tiles is in your network, built on or not. A new Link must touch a location in your network.
Source: BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
Do my Industry tiles stay in my network if an opponent cuts my Links off?
Yes. A location with one of your Industry tiles is always in your network, even an isolated one built with a Location card, and you can build new Links out of it.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum
Can I use an opponent's Links to build with an Industry card?
No. The Industry card needs a location in your own network. Opponents' Links do count for connections, so you can move coal, beer and sales along them.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can I build a Link that only closes a loop or blocks someone?
Yes, as long as it touches your network. It still scores at the end of the era.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can two players place a Link on the same line?
No. Each canal or rail line holds one Link tile.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Are Link tiles limited? Official
Yes. You have only the 14 printed Link tiles of your colour.
Source: BGG thread
Can a Network route pass through an external market?
Yes. A connection is traced along Link tiles, and the type of location along that route does not break it. Merchant market spaces can lie between connected locations, even with a blank Merchant tile. Markets on different sides of the board are not linked to each other.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum
Do I need Industry tiles along a route for it to connect?
No. Any unbroken chain of Link tiles, owned by anyone, connects two locations, through empty and full locations alike. That is enough to sell or to take coal; the far end does not have to be in your network.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum
Can I build or link in locations whose cards are out of the deck at 2 or 3 players? Official
Yes. Those cards are removed only to tighten the game; the locations stay open to Industry cards (in your network), Wild Location cards and Links. You can also link to merchant locations that have no Merchant tile.
Source: BGG thread · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
What can I do when I have no tiles on the board?
You may place a Link on any open line (a rail Link still needs coal), use an Industry card to build that industry on any open matching space, Farm Breweries included, or use a Location card as usual. Once you have a tile on the board, new Links must touch your network again.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
If an opponent's first Link reaches a Farm Brewery, is it locked away from me? Official
Not if you also have nothing on the board: a Brewery card or Wild Industry card can build there under the no-tiles rule.
Source: BGG thread · BGG Rules forum
Two Coal Mines are equally close. Can I take coal from both? Official
No. Choose one and take all the coal you need from it. Move to the next closest mine only when it runs out.
Source: BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
Can I use coal from a mine in the same location without any Links?
Yes. A location is connected to itself at a distance of zero, so that mine is also the closest one and must be used first.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum
Can I buy from the Market while a connected mine or Iron Works still has cubes?
No. Use a connected unflipped Coal Mine first, and any unflipped Iron Works first; the Market is only for when none is available. Coal from the Market needs a connection to a coal icon at a merchant location; iron needs no connection.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Is the coal connection checked before or after the tile is placed?
After. A rail Link or Industry tile that creates its own connection to a mine or a coal merchant can use that coal, and distance is counted from where the new tile is.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
In a double rail Network action, which Link needs coal and which needs the beer?
Each Link needs its own coal, checked after it is placed. The beer must come from a Brewery, not a Merchant; an opponent's Brewery must be connected to the second Link after it is placed, while your own Brewery needs no connection.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I sell coal or iron to the Market in a later turn?
No. Cubes move to the Market only during the action that builds their tile.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
What if we run out of coal or iron cubes? Official
The General Supply is meant to be unlimited. In the rare case you run short, borrow cubes from the top spaces of the Market and put them back there when they are used up. The Iron Market has ten spaces; the top one is only a picture.
Source: BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
When can I use Merchant beer?
Only during a Sell action and only for a sale to the Merchant beside that beer. If you use it, take that Merchant's bonus. Beer needed for the same Industry tile can come from a Brewery as well, but another Merchant's beer cannot be substituted.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Do I get a Merchant's bonus if I use beer from elsewhere? Official
No. The bonus goes only to the player who takes the free beer beside the Merchant they are selling to.
Source: BGG thread
A tile needs two beer. Can both come from Merchants?
No. One sale goes to one Merchant and can use at most that Merchant's one barrel. The second beer must come from a Brewery.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum
Where can a Sell action's beer come from?
From any of your own unflipped Breweries, with no connection needed; from an opponent's Brewery connected to the tile; or from the Merchant you are selling to. Beer has no closest-source rule, so choose freely.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Does every tile need beer to sell? Official
No. A tile that shows no beer icon sells without beer.
Source: BGG thread · BGG Rules forum
Do the tiles in one Sell action have to be connected to each other?
No. Each tile only needs its own connection to a Merchant that buys it, plus its beer.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Two Merchants at one location buy my goods. Must I sell to the more specific one?
No. Choose either, even to take the beer an opponent wanted.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does a blank Merchant tile get beer? Official
No. Blank Merchants buy nothing and get no beer, at setup or between the eras. The location still connects for buying and selling coal.
Source: BGG thread · BGG Rules forum
Does the Develop bonus cost iron? Official
No. It removes one tile for free, with no iron. It is a single tile, not a full Develop action.
Source: BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
Do Merchant tiles flip or move after use?
No. They stay face up for the whole game; the back is only for shuffling at setup.
Source: BGG Rules forum
How many tiles does Develop remove, and what does it cost?
One or two tiles for one card, paying one iron per tile. Each must be the lowest tile left of its industry when you remove it; the two can be different industries.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I build the level 1 Pottery in the Rail Era? Official
Yes, in either era. It scores and is removed at the end of the era in which you built it. Level 3 Pottery can score in both eras.
Source: BGG thread · BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
Can I Scout while holding a Wild card?
No, not even by discarding it as one of the three cards. Use the Wild card first.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Can I Scout with fewer than three cards?
No. Scout always discards three cards, so late in an era it may be impossible.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Is the Wild Location card stronger than the Wild Industry card? Official
Slightly, on purpose.
Source: BGG thread
Can I take a Loan on my first turn, or after the deck runs out?
Yes, at any time as an action, as long as it doesn't drop you below income level −10. From the starting space (level 0) one Loan takes you to the top of level −3. Unlike the earlier game, there is no end-of-game Loan restriction.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · BGG thread · Roxley rulebook
Where does the Income marker go after a Loan?
On the highest space of the new, lower income level, wherever it was within the old one.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
What if I can't pay negative income?
Pay the Bank. If you are short, remove your own Industry tiles for half their cost (rounded down) until you can pay; they leave the game and their resources go back to the supply. If that is still not enough, lose 1 VP per £1 short, as far as you can; the rest is dropped.
Source: BGG Rules forum · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Do I collect income at the end of the Canal Era?
Yes. The last Canal round ends like any other round, with turn order and income, before the end-of-era steps. Only the last round of the game pays no income.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Are Merchant tiles rearranged between the Canal and Rail Eras?
No. Leave them in their setup positions. After Canal scoring, refill each empty beer space beside a non-blank Merchant; then shuffle the Discard Piles and deal new Hands.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
When do flipped Industry tiles score victory points?
At the end of each era. Flipping raises income immediately, but the VP value printed on the tile is counted only during era scoring.
Source: BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
If players finish with the same VP total, how is the winner decided? Official
By highest income, then by most money; players still tied share the win. The rulebook doesn't say whether "income" means the income level or the space on the track. Forum players usually compare track spaces (furthest along wins), and a player relayed a message from co-designer Matt Tolman saying the same, but no designer has posted that answer directly.
Source: BGG thread · BGG Rules forum · Roxley rulebook
Is there any difference between the day and night sides of the board?
No. Only the artwork differs.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Why does the Brewery V tile show one beer for the Canal Era? Official
A printing slip. It can only be built in the Rail Era, where it gets two beer as normal.
Source: BGG thread